Thursday, 27 September 2018

Dissent with the Aadhar

Honourable Supreme court Justice Chandrachud has delivered a dissent judgement on Aadhar yesterday...Here an honest criticism of it.

Justice observes that Aadhar reduces a individual to 12 digit number...

Does justice agree with chaos in diversity scenario, where , individuals are divided on d basis of religion, caste, color etc etc and ders pilferage of unthinkable amounts in providing even basic essentials by govt. or would he prefer an alphanumeric identity of indian residents instead of just numeric one (on a lighter note)

Justice asked " Why has aadhar been made sole repository of information?"
We have so many identity proofs. Many have multiple PANs(to swindle money), Voter IDs(to vote twice), Passports (to run away with borrowed capital)... Many have them in advertently, because there are flaws in d system in which service providers run away from doing their task responsibly and look for shortcuts.

How does Justice prefer this kind of system, than a system where a unique identity number, even if made illegally or by error of omission and commision can be easily de duplicated because parameters of identification are unique?

Justice observes state has failed to demonstrate that a less intrusive measure than a biometric authentication which would not subserve it purpose...

Which other non biometric system in the country has been able to serve it's main purpose better than aadhar???
Does justice consider, United States, a police state which uses intrusive methods to identify it's citizens and targets it citizen's fundamental rights?
When one applies for U.S visa own has to provide biometric information so  that they can check if appilacnt does not have known  criminal antecedents. A child has to go through lice detection test on admission and at regular intervals in schools.

The judge held the passage of the Aadhaar Act as a Money Bill unconstitutional. Passing of the Aadhaar Act as a Money Bill by superseding the Rajya Sabha was a “fraud on the Constitution"

Do Rajya Sabha MPs debate and vote for and against bills on merits or the basis of their party/ alliance affiliations?? This one isn't a difficult one for anyone who understands indian politics... It is agreed that informed discussion does take place in upper house but what has it amounted to when Supreme courts and high courts is either firefighting or on many days doing the job of lawmakers in courts? It feels nice to say the we have 3 pillars in democracy but do we really trust legislation pillar with our life and well being in a "welfare state" as some so called intellectuals like to call our state?

Like all 5 judges, I agree that Aadhar data leaks have proved that UIDAI data structuring and security has serious flaws and we need to adopt best practises....
it's a welcome step to disallow pvt entities from mandatory taking aadhar data and biometrics but does it amounts to throw an above average kid out of class. Instead we as a society have to work with it and force executives in making it a leak proof data. Also service providers should be provided with better means to identify beneficiary than just fingerprints as it's not a smooth fast track process to authenticate  children under 10 and adults over 50 yrs of age. But there are still  ways in which genuine service providers are making customer' as well as their own job much easier with Aadhar.

No comments:

Post a Comment