Sunday, 28 January 2018

OPEN LETTER TO SWARA BHASKAR

Dear SWARA,
 You are a pretty good actor yourself, but it seems you are psychologically handicapped as far as appreciating some superb film making is concerned.... You accuse Sanjay Leela Bhansali of reducing 13th century Indian women to a VAGINA in his Magnum opus PADMAVATI. You accuse him of portraying women as vaginas who were mere prize for kings and sultans.

I feel people like you and many other JNU alumni feel as if they live in seclusion, away from Indian society. You people feel that you can have a world that you wish, without even working for it. Sanjay Leela Bhansali dsn't glorify JAUHAR or SATI in his movie. In fact, sane minds are thinking of climax as a cruel practice women used to resort to for saving their "honour". Meaning of  woman's honour should change but one JN, cant change mind of 1.3 billion Indians. You are going bonkers over polygamy practiced by kings and sultans in 13-14th century but you don't even seem to know that about 2 percent of Hindus and Muslims and much higher percentage of tribals still practice polygamy in India in spite of the fact that its illegal as per Hindu code bills passed in 1950s. Also,Supreme Court has also declared in Feb, 2015 that polygamy isn't integral part of Islam.

Saturday, 27 January 2018

PADMAVATI...

Two and half months before movie PADMAVATI finally released,  MK Vishvaraj Singh, a royal member of Udaipur's Mewar , penned a letter to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the Union Ministers, Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) chief Prasoon Joshi and others, requesting them to withhold the certification and release of the Sanjay Leela Bhansali directorial 'Padmavati.'      

He pointed out that movie is based on imagery poetry of Sufi poet. On the argument that one cannot judge a film until it has been seen, Singh said the first song 'Ghoomar' alone displays an incorrect portrayal of Rani Padmavati.The Rajasthan royal went on to raise concerns about the effect of the movie on the future generation, who will see a distorted history of Mewar. 


I am unable to understand what have these Rajput royals done to showcase Rajputana valor, courage, rich traditions culture and history to rest of India and the world?

For seventy years after independence they have just yawned in their hereditary palaces. Some of the royal ladies/gents have entered in politics and served or a still serving a head of state of Rajsthan. If they had showcased their rich culture to the nation and world ,culture of Rajputana would have been well known to people of nation and no movie could have posed so called threat to culture and traditions of Rajputana. 

More importantly I have watched the fantastically made movie today, and for an outsider to Rajputana culture, The movie has portrayed the culture of Rajputs beautifully, whether or not it is factual portrayal of lives of Rajasthan royals.

The movie has spell binding script and superb acting by whole cast from dear old Raza Muraad to the three big celebrities and even Aditi Rao Hydari.  As per news portals film's BOX office collection mat take a hit by about 35 percent because of this ill founded outrage against an awesome movie. And I suggest that head of these senas should be made to cough up with the loss amount that moviemakers will have to bear because of violent protests.

Can Hindi become India's link language?

Political noise over imposition of Hindi over non-hindi speaking regions of India is on rise after GoI recommended implementation of three language policy to President by making Hindi mandatory in CBSE and central govt. schools all over d country...

Those who agree with the policy claim Hindi can only become link language of nation if children are studying it in school.

My take: Studying Hindi till class 10th isn't required for learning good Hindi. I have studied Hindi till class 8th only and my mother tongue is Hindi. Hindi should be an elective subject not mandatory subject for students in 9th and 10 classes everywhere in country. Learning Hindi for three years from 6th to 8th standard is good enough to learn the grammer of hindi language.

Those against making it mandatory in schools claim it's an attempt to belittle their mother tongue. Diversity of nation is under threat. And English is their preferred choice for becoming link language of country.

My take: I believe this insecurity of people in some states when it comes to propagation and use of Hindi in country as link language is baseless. Learning another language has no effect on mother tongue as it stays with you till your last breath. About prospects of English becoming link language of country... barring few north eastern and 4 southern states Hindi is already link language of country. Having a link language is about people across d country interacting with each other. Only an english medium educated person ll be able to speak in English. Propagation of Hindi hasn't had any adverse impact on Marathi, Odisi or Gujrati language or culture so all this insecurity is unfounded.

In stead of making 1.2 billion Indians learn English and making them global citizens in one go, we can catch low hanging fruit of making India a wee linked nation which ensures that diversity of each region or cultures of people are conserved and respected by regions of other states. By having a link language we would be able to understand and respect each other's cultures, better.