Sunday, 18 November 2018

Four years of Kerala...

    It has been about four years since I moved to Kerala... I have lived most of the part of my stay in Kerala at Thiruvananthapuram,the state capital. I get to meet hundreds of people daily as coz my job requires it.

It is a state which can boast of low crime rate, maximum literacy, sound healthcare infrastructure, low infant mortality, lowest decadal population growth rate.

  Consumers in Kerala demand high standards of work ethic from public sector and government which should be emulated everywhere else in the country... But when it comes to private entereprise whatever little private industry Kerala has ,is not accountable the consumers... There is little state intervention to introduce fair competition.

   Even things as small as quality ice creams are hard to get.. There are poor quality local brands which cannot match better country made brands like Amul, Mother diary, Vadilal .....But still one can't get an Amul or a Kwality walls easily in Thiruvanntapuram district...

   Telecom service provoders/ISPs like Airtel, Tata sky or Videocon or any other dth service providers provide poor quality service in terms of set up of new connection, disinstallation or reinstallation.

  Movers and packers, even the renowned ones , tell things like - " Sir, we will move yours good but you ll have to take care of unloading and loading of good and the charges incurred"

  To someone who could not understand it's called NOOKU KOOLIE- a euphimism for extortion by organized labour unions in Kerala under which wages are paid to trade union activists for allowing common householders/ investors/builders to unload belongings/materials using machines or their own labour.

  On 2018 May 1,this year in 21 century, an official release from the Kerala CM Pinarayi Vijayan office said that trade unions had offered full support to the state government's move to end 'nokku kooli' in the state and 'Nokku kooli' to become history

  Courier services are so bad that one thanks the courier personnel when a shipment in delivered in time  like a one thanks a doctor when a healthy baby is delivered.

 Defense pensioners, who are skilled security men work as masons, painters, auto rickshaw drivers as there is not much industry, hotels, shopping complexes to guard or regulate.

There are hartals called by opposition as well as party in power regularly. Representatives of political groups barge into offices sometimes and ask businesses to conform. Sadly, the people not just fear this kind of politics but have started to enjoy it. A hartal day is celebrated as holiday and not as time wasted.

Thursday, 27 September 2018

Dissent with the Aadhar

Honourable Supreme court Justice Chandrachud has delivered a dissent judgement on Aadhar yesterday...Here an honest criticism of it.

Justice observes that Aadhar reduces a individual to 12 digit number...

Does justice agree with chaos in diversity scenario, where , individuals are divided on d basis of religion, caste, color etc etc and ders pilferage of unthinkable amounts in providing even basic essentials by govt. or would he prefer an alphanumeric identity of indian residents instead of just numeric one (on a lighter note)

Justice asked " Why has aadhar been made sole repository of information?"
We have so many identity proofs. Many have multiple PANs(to swindle money), Voter IDs(to vote twice), Passports (to run away with borrowed capital)... Many have them in advertently, because there are flaws in d system in which service providers run away from doing their task responsibly and look for shortcuts.

How does Justice prefer this kind of system, than a system where a unique identity number, even if made illegally or by error of omission and commision can be easily de duplicated because parameters of identification are unique?

Justice observes state has failed to demonstrate that a less intrusive measure than a biometric authentication which would not subserve it purpose...

Which other non biometric system in the country has been able to serve it's main purpose better than aadhar???
Does justice consider, United States, a police state which uses intrusive methods to identify it's citizens and targets it citizen's fundamental rights?
When one applies for U.S visa own has to provide biometric information so  that they can check if appilacnt does not have known  criminal antecedents. A child has to go through lice detection test on admission and at regular intervals in schools.

The judge held the passage of the Aadhaar Act as a Money Bill unconstitutional. Passing of the Aadhaar Act as a Money Bill by superseding the Rajya Sabha was a “fraud on the Constitution"

Do Rajya Sabha MPs debate and vote for and against bills on merits or the basis of their party/ alliance affiliations?? This one isn't a difficult one for anyone who understands indian politics... It is agreed that informed discussion does take place in upper house but what has it amounted to when Supreme courts and high courts is either firefighting or on many days doing the job of lawmakers in courts? It feels nice to say the we have 3 pillars in democracy but do we really trust legislation pillar with our life and well being in a "welfare state" as some so called intellectuals like to call our state?

Like all 5 judges, I agree that Aadhar data leaks have proved that UIDAI data structuring and security has serious flaws and we need to adopt best practises....
it's a welcome step to disallow pvt entities from mandatory taking aadhar data and biometrics but does it amounts to throw an above average kid out of class. Instead we as a society have to work with it and force executives in making it a leak proof data. Also service providers should be provided with better means to identify beneficiary than just fingerprints as it's not a smooth fast track process to authenticate  children under 10 and adults over 50 yrs of age. But there are still  ways in which genuine service providers are making customer' as well as their own job much easier with Aadhar.

Wednesday, 30 May 2018

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS ON STRIKE

It's 31 May 2018 today and the second day of strike called by bankers in opposition of paltry raise of two percent offered by IBA during negotiations for 11 bipartite settlement to unions, representing bank employees. Non Performing Assets of banks have risen steeply during past few years after Raghuram Rajan, previous RBI governor rightly ordered bankers to declare are hidden NPAs in Indian banking system. 

There are many citizens asking the logic behind the banker's strike when losses of Public sector banks are so high. But these people just see numbers and not the reasons behind these numbers. One of the main reasons of rising NPAs is the "relaxed" lending norms especially for corporate honchos when their financial status and credit rating is not analyzed properly. Public Sector banks provide around 80% of the credit to industries and it is this part of the credit distribution that forms a great chunk of NPA.

                Few years ago, when kingfisher was marred in financial crisis, Public sector banks provided it huge amount of loan which it is not able to recover from it. I have mentioned this case as its most talked economic offense in Indian history.  Bailout to Kingfisher airlines was provided by banker after fugitive Economic offender Vijaya Malaya approached the then Prime Minister Manmohan Singh for bailout. I have attached links to support by above statement.

https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/business/companies/kingfisher-loan-did-former-pmo-finance-minister-bail-out-vijay-mallya-947587.html

http://www.dnaindia.com/india/report-kingfisher-needs-to-be-helped-out-manmohan-singh-1611704

               All governments have over the history of Indian banking have dictated to PSBs, who they will lend to. Government of India appoints Board of Directors and CMD of PSBs through DoPT (Department of Personnel and Training). And all big loans are sanctioned by top management of banks. Just like every other sphere of industry, there has been good Directors, Chairmen and CEOs and there have been "not so good" ones.

Present government led by Prime Minister Narendra Modi has introduced schemes like Pradhan manthi Jan Dhan Yojana, Pradhan Manthi Suraksha Yojana, Pradhan Manthi Suraksha Yojana Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana etc. through Banks.Previous government also had few schemes like BSBDA(Basic saving bank deposit accounts), WBCIS(Weather based crop Insurance scheme etc. Private banks do not contribute much to government public service schemes because it does not suit their mono focused profit making agendas. I have attached a link below to educate readers about contribution of Pvt Sector banks implementation of all these schemes.

https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/money-and-banking/why-private-banks-lag-on-the-jandhan-front/article6801622.ece

              It is the PSBs, which do financial public service in India. These banks were nationalized solely for that purpose because India was a poor country and poor Indians required financial literacy and access to banking services. Over the years after nationalization of PSBs , there was trickle down effect of govt. and RBI"s policies so banking reached to poor households too but not in huge numbers. Last four years have seen over 31.67 crore beneficiaries have been connected to formal banking channel as per PMJDY website. As on May 2018, nearly 13.53 crore Indian residents have enrolled under PMSBY. Similarly, nearly 5.35 crore people have enrolled under PMJJBY. As per Mudra website, over 12 crore 90 lakh MUDRA loans and an amount of 6 Rs lakh crore has been sanctioned. These loans loans are for enterprising individuals, micro and small entities who want to start or upgrade a business/enterprise and as is well known there is a large probability of start ups to fail. So, bankers know that a large number of micro loans will not be re-payed and will be waived by government.
As on May 14, 2018, nearly 13.53 crore people had enroled under PMSBY, with almost 1.5 lakh joining it on a weekly basis
As on May 14, 2018, nearly 13.53 crore people had enroled under PMSBY, with almost 1.5 lakh joining it on a weekly basis
As on May 14, 2018, nearly 13.53 crore people had enroled under PMSBY, with almost 1.5 lakh joining it on a weekly basis
As on May 14, 2018, nearly 13.53 crore people had enroled under PMSBY, with almost 1.5 lakh joining it on a weekly basis
As on May 14, 2018, nearly 13.53 crore people had enroled under PMSBY, with almost 1.5 lakh joining it on a weekly basis.

As on May 14, 2018, nearly 13.53 crore people had enroled under PMSBY, with almost 1.5 lakh joining it on a weekly basis.
As on May 14, 2018, nearly 13.53 crore people had enroled under PMSBY, with almost 1.5 lakh joining it on a weekly basis.

             In spite of lending to corporates as per govt. wishes and advise of top managements appointed by them. And contributing to nation building as per govt. policy by implementing the numerous schemes started by them, knowing well that these schemes were welfare schemes and made little business sense, bankers are being asked the logic of going on strikes because banks are making losses and have lakhs of crores in NPAs.

     I have this to say to them: 


Firstly, Pay all your loans in time in stead of going for one time settlements with banks after months of no repayments even if you earn handsomely.

Secondly,Ask govt.s to give autonomy to banks in appointment of board officials...  so that banks can decide if they wish to give loans to Adani, Dhoot, bailout Mallaya or not.



Thirdly, Let bankers decide the number  BSBDA and JAN DHAN accounts each branch can open because majority of these account holder are  illiterate. Dey r scared of AAAM PAPAD(plastic money) and internet banking they visit branch fr inquiring about each SMS they get on their free JIO phones.
 

Fourthly,Don't make hue and cry when PSBs levy Monthly Average Balance, SMS and account closure charges. Let Public sector banks charge Rs 20 paisa for counting each bank note over 500 notes because that is the rate charged by many private banks...


Lastly, Ask govt.s to keep out, if banks deny loans on genuine reasons and also give acknowledgement of receipt for loan applications. Even Banking Ombudsman can't question banks on their decision of not lending to but CMO and PMO and offices of various politicians do.





AND THEN P.S. BANKERS WILL LOVE TO ACCEPT RAISE IN CONFORMITY WITH PROFITS OF THEIR BANKS.
 

Sunday, 6 May 2018

Another partition of Indian sub-continent


Post independence, when most of fanatically communal muslims moved to Pakistan, communal Hindus stayed because whole basis of partition was communal, although they didn't agree with our secular constitution drafted largely by congress and communist leaders. Communal Hindus must have been in crores among 35 crore Indian population and they were not involved in constitution making... Pre-independence Indian National Congress leaders had ignited the fight for freedom from British colonialism in minds of commons as well as poorest of the poor. So, congress carried huge political capital when partition and independence took place.

I can't read mind of long assassinated M.K. Gandhi but when he said "he wished PRE-EXISTING congress is disbanded" , a non political person can read between the lines of his Last will and Testament, printed in Harijan, next day of his assassination and understand he saw a future of Congress in Indian polity but not in its pre-independence form. Maybe, he did not want Congress leaders to appropriate freedom struggle to themselves and the party to use it for political benefits.

One the other side, banned RSS started to gain traction with communal hindus in India. Post independence Congress leadership strategy of appropriating freedom struggle, worked for a couple of decades with communal hindus but RSS got it's real political chance post emergency when Congress was "effectively" divided. Since then, RSS and it's political offshoots are on steady rise. Reason being, we have a large population of communal hindus among us. Although fanatics among hindus, who join Bajrang dal, Karni Sena etc. would be few decimal percentage of Indian Hindu population but those who form core vote base of BJP, MNS, SHIV SENA etc would be much large in numbers. Also there are crores of those who do not allow religious intermingling, inter religious marriages etc Say, we call them conservatives, are living amongst us, maybe sharing same roof with us...These are also BJP, SHIV SENA, MNS, SAD electorate.

So, if practitioners of Nehruvian secularism wish for Nehruvian secular nation then they can ask for banning of RSS, BJP, BAJRANG DAL, KARNI SENA, SHIV SENA etc. Members and hard core supporters of these organization could be 15 to 20 crores and then there would be equal number of conservatives which make up swing votes during elections conservatives. They vote for Modi when he brags about requirement of 56 inch chest for handling Pakistan. Those conservatives which, Rahul Gandhi tries to woo, when he visits temples as if he's attending some public event.

See around yourself and calculate the number of your cousins, kin , parents , friends, teachers, neighbors who may protest or support these hindu right-wing and communal organizations. What if they ask for their right to be, what they are. What if, they wish for their own Hindu Rashtra because they do not agree with your secularism.

P.S. Dividing people on the bases of their ideological or political choices is easy but what we have done in last 70 years is far more difficult task.  If we go a decade back in time,  We were not calling each other names on the basis of our political or ideological choices,like we are today. Narendra Modi or Rahul Gandhi have not coined these names or have asked us to do it.

Sunday, 28 January 2018

OPEN LETTER TO SWARA BHASKAR

Dear SWARA,
 You are a pretty good actor yourself, but it seems you are psychologically handicapped as far as appreciating some superb film making is concerned.... You accuse Sanjay Leela Bhansali of reducing 13th century Indian women to a VAGINA in his Magnum opus PADMAVATI. You accuse him of portraying women as vaginas who were mere prize for kings and sultans.

I feel people like you and many other JNU alumni feel as if they live in seclusion, away from Indian society. You people feel that you can have a world that you wish, without even working for it. Sanjay Leela Bhansali dsn't glorify JAUHAR or SATI in his movie. In fact, sane minds are thinking of climax as a cruel practice women used to resort to for saving their "honour". Meaning of  woman's honour should change but one JN, cant change mind of 1.3 billion Indians. You are going bonkers over polygamy practiced by kings and sultans in 13-14th century but you don't even seem to know that about 2 percent of Hindus and Muslims and much higher percentage of tribals still practice polygamy in India in spite of the fact that its illegal as per Hindu code bills passed in 1950s. Also,Supreme Court has also declared in Feb, 2015 that polygamy isn't integral part of Islam.

Saturday, 27 January 2018

PADMAVATI...

Two and half months before movie PADMAVATI finally released,  MK Vishvaraj Singh, a royal member of Udaipur's Mewar , penned a letter to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the Union Ministers, Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) chief Prasoon Joshi and others, requesting them to withhold the certification and release of the Sanjay Leela Bhansali directorial 'Padmavati.'      

He pointed out that movie is based on imagery poetry of Sufi poet. On the argument that one cannot judge a film until it has been seen, Singh said the first song 'Ghoomar' alone displays an incorrect portrayal of Rani Padmavati.The Rajasthan royal went on to raise concerns about the effect of the movie on the future generation, who will see a distorted history of Mewar. 


I am unable to understand what have these Rajput royals done to showcase Rajputana valor, courage, rich traditions culture and history to rest of India and the world?

For seventy years after independence they have just yawned in their hereditary palaces. Some of the royal ladies/gents have entered in politics and served or a still serving a head of state of Rajsthan. If they had showcased their rich culture to the nation and world ,culture of Rajputana would have been well known to people of nation and no movie could have posed so called threat to culture and traditions of Rajputana. 

More importantly I have watched the fantastically made movie today, and for an outsider to Rajputana culture, The movie has portrayed the culture of Rajputs beautifully, whether or not it is factual portrayal of lives of Rajasthan royals.

The movie has spell binding script and superb acting by whole cast from dear old Raza Muraad to the three big celebrities and even Aditi Rao Hydari.  As per news portals film's BOX office collection mat take a hit by about 35 percent because of this ill founded outrage against an awesome movie. And I suggest that head of these senas should be made to cough up with the loss amount that moviemakers will have to bear because of violent protests.

Can Hindi become India's link language?

Political noise over imposition of Hindi over non-hindi speaking regions of India is on rise after GoI recommended implementation of three language policy to President by making Hindi mandatory in CBSE and central govt. schools all over d country...

Those who agree with the policy claim Hindi can only become link language of nation if children are studying it in school.

My take: Studying Hindi till class 10th isn't required for learning good Hindi. I have studied Hindi till class 8th only and my mother tongue is Hindi. Hindi should be an elective subject not mandatory subject for students in 9th and 10 classes everywhere in country. Learning Hindi for three years from 6th to 8th standard is good enough to learn the grammer of hindi language.

Those against making it mandatory in schools claim it's an attempt to belittle their mother tongue. Diversity of nation is under threat. And English is their preferred choice for becoming link language of country.

My take: I believe this insecurity of people in some states when it comes to propagation and use of Hindi in country as link language is baseless. Learning another language has no effect on mother tongue as it stays with you till your last breath. About prospects of English becoming link language of country... barring few north eastern and 4 southern states Hindi is already link language of country. Having a link language is about people across d country interacting with each other. Only an english medium educated person ll be able to speak in English. Propagation of Hindi hasn't had any adverse impact on Marathi, Odisi or Gujrati language or culture so all this insecurity is unfounded.

In stead of making 1.2 billion Indians learn English and making them global citizens in one go, we can catch low hanging fruit of making India a wee linked nation which ensures that diversity of each region or cultures of people are conserved and respected by regions of other states. By having a link language we would be able to understand and respect each other's cultures, better.